Halloween is synonymous with thrills, chills, and, of course, the iconic carved pumpkin! Carving a pumpkin is a fun, creative tradition that truly defines the season.
In this guide, we'll walk you through selecting the right pumpkin, explore popular varieties, reveal the history behind the tradition, and provide an easy step-by-step carving guide. Finally, find out where to buy the most beautiful pumpkins at Carpenters Nursery.

How to Choose the Perfect Carving Pumpkin
Starting with the right pumpkin is key to a beautiful end result. Keep these tips in mind when selecting your gourd:
- Shape: Look for a symmetrical shape. This makes it much easier to plan and execute your design evenly.
- Firmness: Give it a gentle squeeze. The shell should feel firm all over; soft spots are often a sign of early rot.
- Stem: The stem should be sturdy and healthy. A robust stem indicates a fresh, well-preserved pumpkin.
- Size: Choose a size appropriate for your design. For detailed or elaborate faces, opt for a medium to large pumpkin that gives you more surface area to work with.

Different types of pumpkins
While there are countless pumpkin varieties, not all are ideal for carving:
-
Jack O'Lantern: Best for Carving. Large, sturdy, and have a smooth, thin skin—perfect for beginners and experts alike.
-
Sugar Pie: Best for Eating. Smaller and sweet, making them ideal for pies and baking, but their dense flesh makes them difficult to carve.
-
Cinderella: Best for Decor. Known for their beautiful orange colour and flat, ribbed shape. Great for stacking but less ideal for traditional carving.
-
Blue Hubbard: Good for Large Carvings. These large, bluish-grey pumpkins offer a huge canvas for complex, detailed designs.

Why We Carve Pumpkins on Halloween
The tradition of carving faces into gourds actually comes from the Irish legend of "Stingy Jack," a wandering soul who was doomed to carry a light inside a carved turnip to guide his way. Early Irish immigrants brought this tradition to North America, where the native pumpkin proved to be a much better, softer carving material than a turnip.
Today, it has evolved from a mythic ward against evil spirits into a fun, creative tradition to decorate your home for the spooky season.
Step-by-Step Guide for Carving
Get ready to create your own glowing ghoul or grinning face!
- Preparation: Clear your workspace and lay down newspapers or a trash bag—this makes cleanup significantly easier.
- Cut the Top: Create a lid by cutting a circular opening around the stem. Angle your knife inward so the lid rests securely and doesn't fall into the pumpkin cavity.
- Hollow it Out: Use a large spoon or a specialized pumpkin scoop to remove all the seeds and stringy pulp. Scrape the inside walls clean for a smooth carving experience.
- Draw Your Design: Use a marker or a stencil to draw your desired design directly onto the pumpkin's surface. Keep it simple with classic spooky eyes or go elaborate!
- Carve the Design: Carefully use a sharp knife or carving tools to cut along the lines of your design. Take your time on detailed areas.
- Light it Up: Place a battery-powered LED light or candle inside the pumpkin to bring your spooky creation to life!

Buy Your Pumpkins at Our Garden Centre
Ready to start carving for Halloween? Visit our garden centre in St. Albans!
We have a wide selection of healthy and beautiful pumpkins, including the ideal 'Jack O'Lantern' variety, ready to give your home the perfect spooky atmosphere. Whether you’re a Halloween fanatic or just starting the tradition, with the right pumpkin and a little creativity, you'll create the most spectacular decorations.
Have fun, and have a spooky Halloween!